Skip to content
Home » Blog » 6 Mistakes Local Businesses Make with Their Social Media Links and Online Listings (and How to Fix Each One)

6 Mistakes Local Businesses Make with Their Social Media Links and Online Listings (and How to Fix Each One)

Small business owner checking a phone behind the counter of a local shop in autumn

It is a slow Tuesday in November and a new customer in Alcona finds your business on Instagram. She taps the link in your bio, and it opens a page that hasn’t been touched in two years. She wants to call, but the phone number on that page is different from the one on Facebook. So she gives up and tries the next business on her list.

This happens more often than most owners realize. Your name, phone number and website link end up on Facebook, Instagram, Google and a handful of directories, and over time they stop agreeing with each other. Good business listings consistency means a customer sees the same details everywhere and lands on a page that helps them call or book.

Here are six common mistakes and how to fix each one.

1. Sending Your Bio Link to a Homepage That Makes People Hunt

Most people tap your link on their phone, often while standing in line or sitting on the couch. If they land on a homepage full of slideshows and menus, they have to dig for the one thing they came for. Many will not bother.

The fix: Decide what your best customer wants to do, then send them straight there. A restaurant might link to the menu and booking page. A contractor might link to a quote request form. A salon might link to online booking.

  • Make sure the page loads quickly on a phone.
  • Put a tap-to-call button near the top.
  • Show your hours and town so people know they are in the right place.

If you run a seasonal promotion, point the link there for a few weeks, then change it back. A link that fits what you are posting about is far more useful than a generic one.

2. Cramming Your Link-in-Bio With Too Many Choices

Link tools make it easy to add ten buttons: your website, your menu, your last three blog posts, your gift cards, your old contest, your email signup. It feels thorough. For the customer, it feels like a pile.

The fix: Keep it to three or four links, in order of what people actually want. For most local businesses that is call or book, see services or the menu, and find us (address and hours).

Once a month, tap every link yourself, on your phone, as if you were a stranger. Remove anything that is expired or broken. A dead link in your bio quietly tells customers that nobody is minding the shop.

Customer making a phone call outside a local storefront on an Ontario main street

3. Letting Your Name, Address and Phone Number Drift

One listing says “Smith & Sons Plumbing,” another says “Smith and Sons,” and a third has a phone number you stopped using. Maybe you moved from Barrie to Innisfil and only updated half the places. Each small difference is easy to ignore, but together they confuse customers and search engines about which details are right.

The fix: Pick one official version of your details and use it everywhere. Write it down exactly:

  • Business name, spelled the way you want it
  • Street address, including suite or unit and postal code
  • One main phone number
  • Website address
  • Service area, such as Innisfil, Bradford West Gwillimbury and Cookstown

Then go through Google, Facebook, Instagram and any directories and make each one match that list. This is the heart of business listings consistency: one set of facts, copied the same way everywhere. If you are not yet on Google and Maps, our Google Placement service ($99) gets your business, contact details and website listed there.

4. Forgetting Hours, Holiday Hours and Seasonal Changes

Nothing frustrates a customer like driving across Newmarket to a shop that Google said was open. Hours change with the seasons, with staffing and with holidays, and the listings are usually the last place anyone remembers to update.

The fix: Treat hours like a small checklist you run through whenever something changes. Update Google first, since that is where many people look, then Facebook, Instagram and anywhere else you are listed.

  • Set special hours for holidays ahead of time. November is a good moment to do it for December.
  • Post a short notice when you close early or take a break.
  • Make sure the hours on your website match the hours on your listings.

Website content goes stale in the same way. Our post on website content update mistakes covers how to keep your own pages fresh without making it a chore.

Two local business owners planning together at a cafe table

5. Leaving Old Listings, Duplicates and Old Web Addresses Live

Many businesses have a few ghosts online. There may be a Facebook page from a former partner, a directory listing from before a rebrand, or a profile that still links to an old website address. Customers find these, and they cannot tell which one is current.

The fix: Search for your business name, and also for your old name, old phone number and old address. Make a note of everything that comes up. Then:

  1. Claim each listing you own and correct it.
  2. Ask to merge or remove duplicates where the platform allows it.
  3. Close pages you no longer use, or at least add a clear note pointing to your current page.
  4. Make sure old web addresses forward to the right place on your current site.

The web address itself matters here too. If you have switched domains or you use a free address from a site builder, check our guide to domain name and business email mistakes so every link you share points to an address you control.

6. Never Checking Back, and Keeping the Logins in One Person’s Head

Setting everything right once is a great start, but things slip again. A new phone line gets added, a staff member changes the Instagram link, or the person who created the Google profile leaves and nobody has the password. Months go by before anyone notices.

The fix: Keep a simple master document with your official details, every place you are listed, and who has access. Then book a short check every three months.

  • Compare each listing against your official details.
  • Tap your bio links on your phone.
  • Check that the contact form or booking page still works.
  • Read and reply to new reviews while you are there.

That last point matters more than it seems, since your listing is often where customers read what others say. Our post on online review mistakes will help you handle that side well. If you would like your Google reviews shown on your own website as well, our Google Reviews add-on ($150) does exactly that.

Start With One Page That Does the Work

All six fixes lead to the same place: a page that helps. Your social profiles and listings are the front doors, and your website is the room people walk into. If the room is clear, with your phone number, hours, services and a way to book, then every link you share does its job.

You do not have to fix everything in a weekend. Start with your bio link and your phone number, since those are the two things customers use most. Then work through hours, old listings and your quarterly check as time allows.

If your website is the weak link, ONLINEid.ca builds custom websites (no generic templates) for businesses across Innisfil, Simcoe County and the GTA, from a simple website from $500 setup to larger projects. We also look after hosting and maintenance, so your details stay correct where it counts.

Jason, your dedicated point of contact at ONLINEid

Book a Free Consultation

If you are not sure where your business details disagree, we can look at it with you. A team member will review your website, listings and social links, then make a plan with you. It costs nothing, and you will leave knowing what to fix first.

Book your free consultation with ONLINEid.ca, or call our A.I. answering line at (289) 807-6364. It answers any time and puts you through to the team.

Website tools by DoctorX.ca